View Full Version : Column Shift or Ground Shift???


Blahman20
04-12-2007, 12:09 AM
What one do you have and what one do you prefer? I have a column shifter, but I think i'd rather have the floor shifter. Maybe it's just because i'm used to the ground shifter from all the other vehicles that i've driven, but the Column shifter gets a little getting used to (I sometimes go by drive or go past reverse)...i'm sure i'll get used to it though. What are your opinions (lol sorry i'm bored...just trying to get some conversation started up :))

lastcoupe
04-12-2007, 12:13 AM
I've got a floorshifter in my blazer and my lumina.......That's the next mod for my Caprice...already have the buckets and console installed just gotta pick me up a good floor shifter and that's that. If you can't tell...I prefer the floor mounted shifter.

BobTheBlazer
04-12-2007, 12:25 AM
Bob has a column shifter but on my Shelby I have a floor shifter...It comes in handy when drag racing...at the strip, of course.

hillbillyinOhio
04-12-2007, 12:49 AM
I have the floor shifter in my 97, but sometimes after i drive the Wrangler (manual) for a few weeks, i forget which truck im driving when i get back into the blazer. I slammed it into Park one day going about 30 mph, I dont think the blazer liked that all that much.

Lee
04-12-2007, 10:36 AM
Wish I had the floor shifter. I go past Drive and Reverse all the time and I've had it for a few months. All my vehicles have had floor ones, I just prefer it.

vagnozzi
04-12-2007, 02:04 PM
column shift on my Jimmy, but I wish it was floor :( I hate removing the dash front for stereo installs with the column shifter, its such a pain :(

Mbastet99
04-13-2007, 01:16 AM
Column shift, but I miss the floor shifter my old Cavalier had, they are much cooler!!

Dabber
04-13-2007, 11:14 AM
There is a link somewhere(i have been looking for it since this thread started) That you can convert your column shifter to a floor shifter in the blazer. I remember this because I am considering it( IIRC it didn't sound that difficult to do) I have the column shifter and I absolutelyhate it. Every vehicle I have ever owned has been a floor shifter.

Lee
04-13-2007, 12:12 PM
Hahahaha! Everyone hates their column shift.

blznlowxtreme
04-14-2007, 12:38 AM
ORIGINAL: Lee

Wish I had the floor shifter. I go past Drive and Reverse all the time and I've had it for a few months. All my vehicles have had floor ones, I just prefer it.
i thought every xtreme wad the floor shifter, i guess i was wrong. i love mine though

Chevy Lover
04-14-2007, 04:35 AM
It depends on how much I like my passenger!
If she's hot, I want a column shifter,[sm=kissykissy.gif]if she's not....floor shifter for sure...

Dabber
04-18-2007, 11:31 PM
This is by NO MEANS mine but thought it might be useful to others. Hope it works



I've already done somewhat of a how-to on this subject before for a 1st gen.. (www.pghconsulting.net/howto (http://www.pghconsulting.net/howto)) This is my second gen one... I don't have some pics, I will add those when it warms up.

Tools Needed:
10mm socket
13mm socket
Drill (Depends on your current center console)
Wire Crimper and butt connectors
T25 Torx
T20 Torx
4.5mm socket (or equivilent reverse torx)
10mm box wrench
Flathead screwdriver
hammer

Parts Needed
Console
Shifter
Misc nuts (try to get the originals that came with it)
washers
Shifter Cable (GM Part # 15713353)
Steering wheel cowl (upper and lower) from a manual shift truck w/ tilt steering (or without tilt if you don't have tilt, get appropriate cowl)

Wiring: Instructions and clarifications at the end of this how-to

Remove old center console. There will be 2 nuts under the arm reset compartment, use a 10mm socket to remove these, then there is a nut to remove under the cup holders, the front just pops off it's clips.

If you have the center console that has the 2 cup holders mounted lenghth wise, then no drilling is required...

Turn the plate so that the wider end is facing towards the front of the truck, there is already a hole there that will fit on the stud that the cup hold section of your old console was on. (Note: You may have to take some of the bow out of the mounting plate to level it right so that the console will sit flush on the carpet, put it on the ground and use a hammer) Use the original nut and tighten down... Trust me that plate won't move. (For those of you with the wide front console where the cup holders are side by side and the retaining nut is under the tray, you will need to drill holes.. Just premount your console and shifter and mark where it needs to be drilled... Use lag bolts to hold it in, see www.pghconsulting.net/howto (http://www.pghconsulting.net/howto) on how to do that)

Mounting Plate:

http://www.pghconsulting.net/howto2nd/plate.jpg

Disconnect your old shifter cable. This will require removing the bottom portion of your steering wheel cowl. Use a t20 torx. You will see where it mounts just below the column shift mechanism. Simply use a flat head screwdriver to pop it off. (Be sure to remove the U clip on there 1st, you will need that clip later) Disconnect the other end from the shifter plate on the detent rod on the tranny. (Use a flat head screwdriver to pop it off) Lift up the driver side carpet and you will see the cable w/grommet going through the floorboard.. Pull that grommet and pull the cable through into the car (or out of the car, your choice) You may have to remove the bracket on the transfer case holding the cable to move it.

(note: this is a first gen picture, but applies to the second gen as well)

http://www.pghconsulting.net/howto2nd/grommet.jpg

Put the new cable in the same way just in reverse, but do not hook it up to the transmission yet. Route the cable under the carpet and through a hole in front of where you mounted the shifter.
http://www.pghconsulting.net/howto2nd/cable.jpg


Put the shifter on top of the plate and add washers to the rear stud to level it out...Just keep loosely putting on the console till it looks like the shifter gear indicator is flush with the console, and the console is flush with the carpet. Secure the shifter to the plate.

http://www.pghconsulting.net/howto2nd/shifter.jpg

Run the cable through the hole in the shifter frame and attach it to the ball-stuf. Insert the U clip into into the base so it doesn't slip out.

Secure the console to the shifter and hump. Use the 2 10mm bolts in the cup holders for the front half, and the 2 10mm nuts under the arm rest compartment to

speeddemon560
04-19-2007, 12:05 AM
I have the column shifter and I think it's great. It doesn't bother me and takes up less space than the ground shifter. Plus I don't like floor shifters because I'm always afraid that if I have 1 or more of my 5 dogs in the car, that they'll knock the shifter and change gears while I'm driving. I wouldn't like that.
I have the cup holders and stuff in the center console because I don't have the floor shifter. Plus, it's not all that difficult removing the dash with a column shifter....

EuroGoldLS
04-19-2007, 12:26 AM
What!? you let dogs in your car!! I would never let a dog in mine unless they are on a basket or a kennel.

I prefer, either. my mom's Envoy has the console shifter, but mine hascolumn. I like the shifter in our 81 Z28, semi-auto.

speeddemon560
04-19-2007, 12:31 AM
I do let dogs in the car. Heres a pic of 4/5 of them.... But yea, as I said before, I prefer the column shifter because it's safer and takes up less space.


http://i168.photobucket.com/albums/u167/speeddemon560/Dogs-1.jpg

Lilcheef
04-19-2007, 02:28 AM
Floor shift for sure. All my Jeeps were floor shift and I think it's way better than colum shift. We have a Dodge Cummins in the family and it has the column shift, I always miss gears on it. I also like to rest my hand on the shifter while it's in drive, can't do that in a column shift and keep your elbow on the center console!!

Laters,
Chris

EuroGoldLS
04-19-2007, 11:52 PM
Why have an automatic Jeep? Not that it matters. My dads'79 CJ7is auto, butI wish so much it was manual, still fun to drive though!

BTW Speedy, how do you tell which dog is which? LOL

Mr Blazer LT
04-20-2007, 03:38 AM
Column shift for sure, (even though I hate automatics) for the space. And Ihave no trouble putting it in D and not accidentally going to 3 or anything. If i'mgonna change gears on the floor,it's manual or bust.

Lilcheef
04-22-2007, 04:35 AM
Well I always had a manual up until I got my Grand Cherokee. That was my first auto and I got lazy. Now i'm a slave to it. My first 3 Jeeps were standard tho, bullet proof let me tell ya. Auto trannys suck for reliability.

drperry
04-22-2007, 08:00 AM
Floor shift for me, lol, Though I wouldn't mind trying a 3 on the tree...

zr2offroad
04-29-2007, 01:24 AM
I have a colume shifter in my Blazer and love it, I cant stand the floor shifter. I also have a Silverado and it's a colume shifter, so I guess I'm just use to it that way.

Scuba65
05-03-2007, 06:06 AM
I'd rather have a floor shifter. We have lots of hills in town, and it's not handy to be shifting out of O/D into D when going downhill, to save on the brakes.

But, I do like my cupholders on the hump...

PJT2007
10-12-2008, 02:41 AM
Man, I dont like that leather boot, not for me, I like the column shifter, out of the way for console space. Does anyone know if their is an alternative to the leather boot? Floor shift is fine, but i don't dig the boot, maybe i can rig somthing up..,, like the slot with the brustles?

kiwiblazer
10-12-2008, 03:01 AM
Grief, I can'tactually remember when last I saw a car witha cloumn shifter. Do they still make them?

drperry
10-12-2008, 04:08 AM
Yep, they do.

mysons95
10-12-2008, 07:22 AM
Mine has a column shifter and I really prefer it over a floor shifter.

More room for pop and stuff in the center area by not having the shifter there.

I do realized that most think it is sportier to have the floor shifter. My camaro had the floor shifter and seemed to fit the vehicle, but the Blazer seems to favor a column for me.

blazerboy124
10-14-2008, 05:56 PM
ive got a floor shift, never owned anything with column

brokenfish
10-17-2008, 01:42 PM
i hate column shifters so after digging for a while i found two shifters that will work with a 4l60e one by lokar i think but it looks just like a manual shifter so i went with the B&M light truck mega shifter it doesnt actually say it works for it but i called and they said i might need another part to make it work but i didnt the thing just went right in and works great its actually a ratchet shift if i had a dog about the only kind that could make this thing change gears is a mastif and if its in your front seat i think him bumping the shifter is the least of your worries

Asimm
10-17-2008, 04:00 PM
can you write up the first gen switch-a-roo bc i cant seem to figure out that website lol

001blazer
11-03-2008, 09:45 PM
I prefere floor shift is 100 times better to shift and it looks 200 times better than column ****., besides that I have 2 floor shifters one on my blazer xtreme and one that I don't use if anyone is intersted let me know.