Crankshaft failure.. New engine questions.
#1
New Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location:
Posts: 72

While driving home from the airport the other day I heard a strange noice while accelerating. I turned down my radio and tried to pass a vehicle. I heard some pinging and the engine shut down. I had it towed to our friends shop and he said the crankshaft snapped. Any one else had an issue with this? What causes this, bad casting? I have decided to go ahead and put a new engine in the truck. I am going to get a Jasper engine. The cost of the engine installed is $3000. I thought this was a little high and wanted some opinions on this. I know that you are supposed to do an inital oil change after 1000 miles. I typically run synthetic but do not want to waste the money on it for flushing the inital break in oil. Any suggestions on that?
#2
if your going stock replacement, why not just get a gm dealership engine? I saw sum on ebay the other day, i`ve actually been watching one for my 93 chevy van.. 1795.00 350 motor, shipped to me ,,,, also what year blazer is it you have and what motor?
#3
New Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location:
Posts: 72

The Jasper engine was cheaper. Same warranty. The blazer is a 99 with a 4.3L, it had 140,000 when it died.
#4
#5
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location:
Posts: 13

You shouldn't use synth for break-in use high quality conventional. Synth Oil is bad for break-in!
#6
Banned
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location:
Posts: 220

A brand new GM 4.3L crate engine costs $2100 + $150 shipping .A rebuilt Jasper engine installed for $3000 is a much better deal . It takes 30 hours shop time to R&R an engine.At $1000, that is $33.33 per hour compared towhat most Chevrolet or GM dealerships would charge, which is$80 to $90 per hour shop time.TheJasper engine is the better cholce even if it is a rebuilt engine. I have used a local Racing Engine shop to do the machine work and rebuild my engines since 1970. That is becauseI can tell them which parts I want to use.
I prefer a used rebuilt .010"-.010" undersize crank rather than a new crank because they were pre-stressedin another engine.The only crank I ever broke was in a new 1965 327 CI factory short-block I was usingin a 1956 Chevy B/MP NHRA dragcar.After that, I decided thatI would never buy a new crate engine or a new crank again.
In 1966, my partner and I were building a Woody Gilmore chassis, SBC Chevy powered Jr. Fuel rear engine dragster and we were going to purchase a new 327 CI cast iron crank and send it to Crankshaft Companyand get them to stroke it for a355 CI engine for the Jr. Fuel class engine.That was a few months before thefactory forged 350 CIcranks wereavailable from GM.Crankshaft Company (CSC) told us to send aUSED327 CI crank because even if they inspected a new 327 CIcrank, they will not stroke itand guarantee it. The told us that there may be hidden casting flaws that magnafluxing cannot detect. A used crank is pre-tested.
I prefer a used rebuilt .010"-.010" undersize crank rather than a new crank because they were pre-stressedin another engine.The only crank I ever broke was in a new 1965 327 CI factory short-block I was usingin a 1956 Chevy B/MP NHRA dragcar.After that, I decided thatI would never buy a new crate engine or a new crank again.
In 1966, my partner and I were building a Woody Gilmore chassis, SBC Chevy powered Jr. Fuel rear engine dragster and we were going to purchase a new 327 CI cast iron crank and send it to Crankshaft Companyand get them to stroke it for a355 CI engine for the Jr. Fuel class engine.That was a few months before thefactory forged 350 CIcranks wereavailable from GM.Crankshaft Company (CSC) told us to send aUSED327 CI crank because even if they inspected a new 327 CIcrank, they will not stroke itand guarantee it. The told us that there may be hidden casting flaws that magnafluxing cannot detect. A used crank is pre-tested.
#7
New Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location:
Posts: 72

Thanks for the reply Duntov. After doing a little research, I found that it was not a bad deal. He said he would only charge me for 11 hrs shop time. Out the door with all the bs and taxes should put me right around $3500.
*Combining Consecutive Posts*
Thanks for the input dtetreau. Do you know why it is bad for break in? Just wondering.
*EDIT by swartlkk* - Please use the EDIT feature to add additional information to your post if another member has yet to reply. When replying to multiple people in a post, please do so with one post, not multiples. Consecutive posting is against forum rules. Please feel free to PM me to discuss further. Thanks!
*Combining Consecutive Posts*
Thanks for the input dtetreau. Do you know why it is bad for break in? Just wondering.
*EDIT by swartlkk* - Please use the EDIT feature to add additional information to your post if another member has yet to reply. When replying to multiple people in a post, please do so with one post, not multiples. Consecutive posting is against forum rules. Please feel free to PM me to discuss further. Thanks!
#8
New Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location:
Posts: 72

Thanks for the input dtetreau. Do you know why it is bad for break in? Just wondering.
#9
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location:
Posts: 532

Synthetic oil doesn't allow the wear-in that rings and things need to properly seat and seal.
#10
Starting Member
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Michigan
Posts: 111

my jasper installed was 5200 OTD.. but i got the Jasper install kit as well.. wish it was only 3000... my long block alone was 2600.00.. i did get the "performane" model.. but without a pcm tune its not really notice able.. just sounds mean ( i have bigger ported heads).
and NEVER you synthetic oils for break ins.. my break in period was 500 than i got another basic oil change, than after 3,000 (3500 all together) i went to full synthetic...
and NEVER you synthetic oils for break ins.. my break in period was 500 than i got another basic oil change, than after 3,000 (3500 all together) i went to full synthetic...





