I'm having a very similar issue. I just ordered a feul pressure gauge off of amazon, They are $40 + free shipping. Assuming it is the pump, how much should I expect to pay to get it replaced? I just moved to IN from MN and am currently in an apartment w/ no garage. I don't know that I feel comfortable dropping the fuel tank in the parking lot. Goodyeaer wanted $900 and change, that seems a bit overkill. They said the pump was $618, but they sell it at NAPA for $278.