I finally pulled the trigger on some new tires and wheels. The wheels have 0 offset, so they come out of the finder wells just a touch. I'm also surprised that the mud tires don't make more noise when highway driving.

Because of the offset I've had to trim back the front wheel wells inside. They still rub when off-roading, so I'll need to trim some more, but I'm happy with how they turned out.

 

Man that thing is in good shape. I like red blazers with black wheels. Nice work.