I'd personally probably go with a vynal over paint and something more gloss to try to blend with the glass a little better. My .02 at least

 

I guess that same thing could be said about the ideas too...


Not sure if there was a point behind you saying that... because I fail to see one.

 

I'm with nunya on this one! Maybe if you did it in a gloss finish so it looked more like a a continuation of the glass all the way through it would look better. I have seen a few pics of 2 door guys doing it and it looked pretty good IMO.

 

If it was gloss, It would look much better, The flat looks very out of place.

 

When/ if you do this, repaint the rear plastic D pillars at the same time. Soos all match in color and texture.IMO

 

ya just paint it gloss black, you can always take it off with thinner.